Table of Contents
Top Pie Shops to Try
Baked by Susan – 379 S Riverside Ave, Croton-on-Hudson, NY
This old‑fashioned bakery is famous for handmade pies with all‑butter crusts. Favorites include sour cherry, pumpkin, mixed berry, and pecan—and yes, they also make incredible savory chicken pot pies.
The Baker’s Daughter – 14 Fair St, Carmel, NY
A sweet café offering deep‑dish seasonal pies like apple, pumpkin, pecan, and chocolate mousse. Perfect for holiday pre-orders or a weekend treat.
Galloway’s Bakery – 69 Harney Rd, Scarsdale, NY
A beloved weekend‑only bakery with lines out the door. Their apple, pecan, pumpkin, and cream pies are iconic Westchester staples.
Noble Pies – 38 Main St, Tarrytown, NY
Known for sweet and savory pies made with local ingredients. Try their butterscotch, cherry crumb, chocolate cream, or a hearty chicken pot pie.
Red Barn Bakery – 4 S Astor St, Irvington, NY
This organic bakery offers seasonal favorites like blueberry, strawberry rhubarb, and apple salted caramel, with vegan and gluten‑free options available.
Bartlett House – 2258 Route 66, Ghent, NY
An artisanal bakery known for elegant holiday pies, including sticky maple pecan, blackcurrant, almond tart, and coconut cream.
Gluten-Free Pie Finds
Red Barn Bakery – 4 S Astor St, Irvington, NY
This 100% organic bakery shines with gluten‑free pies and pastries, including fruit-forward favorites and seasonal specialties like apple salted caramel crumb—all made with care for dietary needs.
Sweetie Pies – Delivery Across Westchester
Offering handmade pies in flavors like strawberry, wild berry, and s’mores, this delivery-based bakery provides mini and full-size options, many of which can be made gluten‑friendly upon request.
Vegan Pie Options
Noble Pies – Tarrytown & Warwick, NY
While best known for traditional pies, Noble Pies also offers vegan‑friendly fruit pies upon request, made with their signature all‑butter‑free crust variations.
Whether you love your pie fruity, creamy, crumb‑topped, or savory, these local spots deliver the freshest, flakiest slices in the valley. Let me know if you want a list of the best holiday pies next!
English